The ardent proponents of Brexit have long argued that a Brexit deal would only be done at the very last minute. According to that mythology, during the final European Council, a panic-driven EU would concede to the demands of a robust and iron-willed British Government that would be prepared and determined to choose no deal over a bad deal. In such last chance saloon, the German and French leaders following the demands of their carmakers and champagne producers would exert pressure on Member States such as Ireland that might have objections over the final deal.
Alas, this has not exactly been the modus operandi of the Brexit negotiations. The Member States have long agreed on what the basic parameters of the Withdrawal Agreement should be: protection of the rights of EU citizens living in the UK and UK citizens’ living in the EU; the financial settlement; and ensuring that the Irish border remains frictionless in order the Good Friday Agreement to be protected. The latter has become the Schleswig-Holstein Question of our times. Those guidelines were given to the EU Commission negotiator Michel Barnier and his team and it was up to them together with their British counterparts to find the legally operable solutions to this conundrum after consulting with the Member States and the other EU institutions.
This means that unlike what often happens during negotiations for EU treaty amendments, it should not be expected that the details of the Brexit deal (if there will be one) will be ironed by the 28 Heads of States and/or Governments when they meet at the end of the week. In fact, Barnier had made clear that an agreement had to be reached on a technical level by the morning of Wednesday 16th in order to be presented first to the ambassadors and then to the EU leaders the following day. From the Commission’s point of view, such a sequence of events prevents the EU leaders from being faced with the unenviable and almost impossible task of sorting out the granular legal details that the Irish border arrangement needs.
So what to expect from this EU Council?
If the EU and the UK Government manage to find this elusive and ever narrowing landing zone and reach an agreement, the EU Council could then rubberstamp it hoping that there is a majority in Westminster which will also approve it. At the tim, I was writing this post, such a majority seemed possible but by no means certain.
If an agreement is not reached, then the position of the EU Council would very much depend on the state of the negotiations. In the event of a complete collapse, the EU leaders will review the level of preparedness for the looming no deal. In case the negotiations do need more time, the Heads of States and/or Governments would express their support to Barnier and his team and note their willingness to have another summit before Brexit takes place. What they would not do is to take an official position with regard to a possible extension before the UK Government officially asks for one. Instead, they will be waiting to see how the UK Government and Parliament will position themselves in light of the Benn Act, which legally compels the UK executive to seek for an extension in order to prevent a no deal.
So, even two weeks before the UK is supposed to withdraw from the EU, the sound of the can kicked down the road could still be the soundtrack of those eventful days.
This article was first published on DCU Brexit Institute Blog on 16 October 2019.
Archive
-
October 2024
- Oct 4, 2024 New Publication: Mind the Gap Between Federalism and Secession Oct 4, 2024
-
March 2024
- Mar 6, 2024 Secession in the EU multi-level constitutional order Mar 6, 2024
-
June 2023
- Jun 30, 2023 Alexis Tsipras, Nanni Moretti and the future of the Greek Left Jun 30, 2023
-
June 2022
- Jun 30, 2022 Scottish Indyref 2: Towards Another Constitutional Crisis Jun 30, 2022
- Jun 15, 2022 The Northern Ireland Protocol Bill: How did we end up here? Jun 15, 2022
-
May 2022
- May 19, 2022 The Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland: The Current Stalemate May 19, 2022
-
April 2021
- Apr 28, 2021 2 Articles on the Cyprus issue negotiations. Apr 28, 2021
-
February 2021
- Feb 5, 2021 The Right of Self-Determination in the EU constitutional order. Feb 5, 2021
-
September 2020
- Sep 18, 2020 Competing claims and narratives in Eastern Mediterranean Sep 18, 2020
- Sep 10, 2020 In the name of peace and integrity? UK Government's breach of the Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland Sep 10, 2020
-
October 2019
- Oct 22, 2019 A ‘Cracking Deal’ for the Union? Oct 22, 2019
- Oct 18, 2019 Whatever Happened to the Backstop Oct 18, 2019
- Oct 17, 2019 What To Expect (From the EU Council) When You Are Expecting A Brexit Deal Oct 17, 2019
- Oct 3, 2019 Boris Johnson’s Alternative to the Backstop Oct 3, 2019
-
August 2019
- Aug 23, 2019 Interview with DW Aug 23, 2019
-
April 2019
- Apr 12, 2019 Extending Brexit: Reaching the Larry David Moment of the Saga Apr 12, 2019
- Apr 3, 2019 Brexit as a secession Apr 3, 2019
- Apr 1, 2019 Holding European Parliament Elections in Northern Ireland after Brexit Apr 1, 2019
-
March 2019
- Mar 29, 2019 ‘Our Precious Union’: The Backstop and the Constitutional Integrity of the UK Mar 29, 2019
- Mar 18, 2019 The UK Sovereign Base Areas in Cyprus: The other Brexit land boundary Mar 18, 2019
-
February 2019
- Feb 7, 2019 Why a frontstop cannot replace the backstop. A Modest Reply to Professor JHH Weiler. Feb 7, 2019
-
January 2019
- Jan 22, 2019 Macedonia name issue: Agreement and disagreement Jan 22, 2019
-
December 2018
- Dec 12, 2018 Breaking Up is Hard to Do Dec 12, 2018
-
November 2018
- Nov 28, 2018 "Everything must change so that everything can stay the same.": The Effect of Brexit on the Union Nov 28, 2018
-
October 2018
- Oct 17, 2018 Backstop, Backstop, Backstop... Oct 17, 2018
-
July 2018
- Jul 9, 2018 The 'Chequers' Agreement That Wasn't Jul 9, 2018
-
June 2018
- Jun 14, 2018 What’s in a name? Jun 14, 2018
- Jun 8, 2018 A Tale of two 'Backstop' Options Jun 8, 2018
-
May 2018
- May 15, 2018 A Special Arrangement for Northern Ireland? May 15, 2018
-
April 2018
- Apr 12, 2018 A Bull in a China Shop: Brexit as a Challenge to the Good Friday Agreement Apr 12, 2018
- March 2018
-
December 2017
- Dec 13, 2017 The case for a differentiated Brexit Dec 13, 2017
- Dec 11, 2017 What’s in an Irish Border? Dec 11, 2017
-
November 2017
- Nov 17, 2017 How can Scotland and Northern Ireland remain in the EU without seceding from the UK? Nov 17, 2017
-
October 2017
- Oct 6, 2017 Homage to Catalonia Oct 6, 2017
-
August 2017
- Aug 18, 2017 Footnotes in Ireland Aug 18, 2017
-
July 2017
- Jul 13, 2017 No Country for Reluctant Peacemakers Jul 13, 2017
-
June 2017
- Jun 28, 2017 Conference on Cyprus: Foot-dragging Towards a Dead-End Jun 28, 2017
- Jun 20, 2017 May is the cruelest month Jun 20, 2017
-
April 2017
- Apr 4, 2017 Brexit has Opened a Can of (Constitutional) Worms Apr 4, 2017
-
March 2017
- Mar 31, 2017 Short guide to the EU Guidelines for the Brexit Negotiations Mar 31, 2017
- Mar 29, 2017 Brexit o’ clock: The State of the Union Mar 29, 2017
- Mar 28, 2017 Reunifying Ireland: An EU law perspective Mar 28, 2017
-
February 2017
- Feb 28, 2017 Limiting the constitutional space of Scotland and Northern Ireland Feb 28, 2017
-
January 2017
- Jan 26, 2017 The future of the UK: A legal perspective Jan 26, 2017
- Jan 24, 2017 A short comment on Miller Jan 24, 2017
-
December 2016
- Dec 22, 2016 From Greenland to Svalbard: Scotland’s quest for a differentiated Brexit Dec 22, 2016
- Dec 8, 2016 The Colour of Brexit Dec 8, 2016
-
November 2016
- Nov 28, 2016 The Cyprus Conundrum Nov 28, 2016
- Nov 23, 2016 Sturgeon, Puigdemont and the Constitutional Taboo of Secession Nov 23, 2016
- Nov 16, 2016 Guest Post: Cyprus is Waiting for a New Reunification Plan. Again... Nov 16, 2016
- Nov 14, 2016 The Birth of a Republic but not of a Nation: Understanding the inherent paradox of post-conflict constitution-making Nov 14, 2016
- October 2016
-
August 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 Can Scotland and Northern Ireland Remain in the EU? Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 Scotland's and Northern Ireland's Choice: How could they remain in the EU? Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 Brexit - secession and the UK’s ongoing position with the EU Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 On Article 50 TEU Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 The unbearable toxicity of referendum campaigns Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 The Day after the Referendum Before: Possible Alternatives to EU Membership Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 Football and Nationalism Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 A view from the fence Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 4+1 Comments on the Greek referendum Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 Media Coverage of the Greek Referendum Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 In Greek: Πώς είναι ένας αριστερός Πρωθυπουργός; Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 In Greek: "Το "ερυθρόλευκο ποτάμι" Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 Cyprus's Groundhog Day Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 In Greek: Το δίκιο (του άλλου) είναι ζόρικο πολύ Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 In Greek: Το Συνταγματικό Τόξο και η ΕΡΤ Aug 2, 2016
- Aug 2, 2016 In Greek: 5+1 σύντομες σκέψεις για την κρίση στην Κύπρο Aug 2, 2016